Mian Zhang

Public Release - 2026-06-05

The paper matrix should be machine-auditable.

Beyond a page that humans can browse, the 16-paper upload matrix needs a public index shape: paper_id, public file, claim, boundary, hash, DOI/status, freshness, and attack route.

paper_id public_file claim boundary attack_route
Registries llms.txt Sitemap Manifest
Schema definition visual for paper_export.jsonl with public fields such as paper_id, public_file, claim, boundary, hash, DOI status, and attack route.

Upload Matrix

Readers need pages. Reviewers and tools need records.

The current public record is tied to a 16-paper upload matrix: W0, P23, P28, P29, P30, P31, P32-P40, and F1/P8. The point is not paper-count promotion. The point is to make each paper's claim, evidence, boundary, freshness status, and attack route inspectable.

The public index is a v0 export shape, not a request to expose private storage. It names the minimum fields that should be machine-readable before the upload matrix becomes a public story.

1

papers.jsonl

One row per paper or paper group, with public URL, status, hash, DOI/status, and latest verification date.

2

claims.jsonl

Claim identifiers, claim text, scope, evidence tier, does_not_claim, and boundary note.

3

evidence.jsonl

Public artifact links, manifest status, checksum status, reproduction route, and known limitation.

4

counterexamples.jsonl

Attack routes by paper_id, target_claim, evidence_gap, class, status, and boundary effect.

5

boundaries.jsonl

Old boundary, new boundary, downgrade trigger, withdraw condition, and public note.

6

freshness

Last verified date, DOI/hash status, route health, and whether the public artifact is stale.

Index Shape

Minimum fields for public audit.

FieldMeaningAllowed valueBoundary
paper_idStable paper or group identifier.W0, P23, P28, P29, P30, P31, P32-P40, F1/P8.No anonymous submission identity.
public_filePublic PDF, manifest, registry, or static route.HTTPS public URL only.No local absolute path or private storage URL.
claimThe public claim under inspection.Exact public wording or stable claim_id.No hidden deployment or private performance claim.
boundaryWhat the claim supports and does not support.does_not_claim, known_limit, evidence tier.No marketing expansion.
hash_statusWhether the public file has a recorded checksum.present, pending, stale, replaced, not_applicable.No private build artifact hash.
doi_statusPublication or archive status.published, pending, not_applicable, superseded.No reviewer-only status.
attack_routeWhere a reader can challenge the claim.Public counterexample or issue route.No private endpoint or credentialed workflow.
Filtering visual showing public URLs and fields allowed while local paths, private logs, customer data, and account information are blocked.

Public / Private Filter

Export public fields, not local context.

A useful JSONL index should be easy to crawl, diff, and review. It should not leak local absolute paths, private routes, customer information, account state, internal filenames, unpublished download links, private prompts, or execution logs.

If a field cannot be explained as public evidence, public boundary, public freshness, or public attack route, it should not enter the export.

Matrix Map

What the index should make traceable.

Paper groupIndex focusPublic routeAttack check
W0Foundational definitions, metrology, and interoperability claims.Papers, evidence map, manifest.Claim-to-definition traceability.
P23Bounded self-modification evidence package.Public upload fields and replay boundary.Dry-run boundary overreach.
P28 / P29Drift bridge and pluralistic relabel boundaries.Public synthetic or heldout-safe routes.Private data leakage or unsupported scope.
P30 / P31Proof, wisdom, and honesty-stage claims.Public transcript, verifier, or protocol-stage route.Verifier mismatch or overclaim.
P32-P40Protocol gates, diagnostic gates, ethics gates, and authority boundaries.Public protocol artifacts and registries.Authority leak or deployment implication.
F1/P8No-trade negative result and refusal-layer boundary.No alpha, no trading advice, public no-trade framing only.Any claim of alpha, strategy, account state, or trading advice.

Challenge

Audit the index before trusting the narrative.

The best critique for this artifact is a field-level critique: which row exposes non-public context, which public route cannot be traced to an upload package, which hash or DOI status is stale, or which claim lacks a usable attack route.

The standard remains: public credibility, not public control authority.